Stephen-
That is another question that is somewhat outside my area of knowledge, but I can tell you what I know. Number can be encoded in DNA in several ways. The most basic is that different individuals can have different numbers of copies of the same gene. Our chromosomes have lots of stretches of DNA that have been duplicated, sometimes many times. Something in the DNA replication process screws up, and you end up repeating a section of the chromosome, like a record skipping while you are making a copy of it. So if I have 2 copies of a gene, and you have 12, that is numeric information. Similar, but not necessarily to the point, are tandem repeats such as microsatellites. This is basically a stutter in (usually non-coding) DNA. A section of chromosome might have ATCATCATCATCATCATCATCATC so that is eight repeats. The other chromosome in the same person could have twelve repeats, and someone else could have 23. These things seem to combine a high mutation rate with very little selective pressure, meaning that they can evolve relatively randomly and very quickly, meaning they are very diverse within a population. For that reason they are often used for genealogical reconstructions and such.
Not exactly numeric, but not binary, is gene expression modulation. Genes are not necessarily just "on" or "off." A wide range of factors can turn up or down the expression a particular gene, including the particulars of the interactions of non-coding DNA in the promoter region at the beginning of that gene with the various promoter or repressers , which can themselves vary in concentration and structure. So the production from a gene is not 0 or 1 but rather can vary continuously from 0 to 1.
On the subject of telomeres, what their length determines is the number of times a cell can divide before its line dies out. This does not so much encode longevity, as take a part in determining the tradeoff between ability to heal and cancer risk. The body has many mechanisms that limit the ability of cells to divide rapidly, which reduces the risk of cancers (which are defined in part by their unchecked cell division)
but also limits healing (which requires cell division). Telomeres are one such mechanism. It is important to keep in mind though that there are enzymes that can extend telomeres, even in adult organisms, and most organisms have telomeres that are much longer than is needed for most of their cell lines to continue dividing throughout their lifetimes, and therefore telomeres are not in any meaningful sense coding for longevity.
I am sure there are other mechanisms of numeric encoding in genetic material, but I don't know what they are.
In response to your question about averaging of parental values, I would say this generally does not happen. For highly heritable traits, the mean value of the offspring should be similar to the mean value of the parents, but it is not the case that every individual offspring will be at or near that mean value. This is a point that is actually extremely important. During Darwin's time, there was a Scottish biologist whose name I can't remember now, who showed mathematically that if offspring get the mean value of their parents, Darwinian evolution does not work very well (effectively because variation is constantly being eliminated). Darwin was stumped for at least a while, until it was pointed out that each offspring does not get that mean value, but rather some value in a range centered on that mean. As an example, my brother is taller than either of my parents (even adjusting for sex) I am about the same height as my parents (again adjusting for sex) and my sister is (again adjusting) shorter than either of my parents.
So I am curious why you are asking all these questions about quantitative genetics. I assume you have had some idea for which genetics is a good analogy?
-Dan
Showing posts with label quantitative genetics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label quantitative genetics. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 15, 2008
Monday, January 14, 2008
Genetic Answer for Stephen: How and why traits vary continuously
Stephen-
There are several factors that can contribute to continuously varying traits, and we have to be careful not to conflate them. They are often divided into two broad categories, genetic factors and environmental factors, although there are often non-linear interactions between these.
On the genetic side, traits come in several flavors. The two state trait, where either you have it or you don't, is the classical Mendelian trait. Peas in a particualr population are white or green. If you have two alleles for green, or one for green and one for white, you make green peas. If you have no alleles that code for the green pigment, you make white peas. Next, as you described, are the three state genetic traits. Still all coded for at one locus, but dosage dependent, you end up with 0 or .5 or 1 full dose of the gene product. This is called incomplete dominance.
Then you get into additive multi-gene traits. Many different genetic loci have can affect human height, as an example. There was one gene, who's name I don't remember, that was recently shown to exhibit incomplete dominance in affecting human height. AA individuals are on average 5mm taller than the background population, Aa individuals are, on average, no different from the background population, and aa individuals are on average 5mm shorter than the mean of the population. But obviously height in humans varies by more than 1cm, so their must be other factors contributing. Some of these factors are genes affecting the length or shape of individual bones. Of those, some are classically dominant, some are incompletely dominant, and some may even be overdominant (where the Bb individual would have a longer bone than the BB or the bb). When you add together the variation in all these genes, you have a huge range of possible combinations, and end up with data that look pretty continuous. But then it gets even more complicated.
Genetic effects are not always additive. Imagine one gene codes for the presence a knob on a bone, and another gene causes that knob to be long or short. If an individual has the allele that causes that knob not to exist, it doesn't matter whether or not it has the allele that would make that knob long. If the knob isn't there, it can't be long. This is called epistasis. The sole effect of many genes, on a molecular level, is to regulate the activity of other genes. One gene makes a protein that carves up the protein product of a second gene, preventing that second protein from binding to a particular point on a chromosome where it would keep a third gene from being transcribed. Raise the temperature slightly, and the first protein changes conformation, and lets the second protein be, which cuts off production of the thrid gene. But if the Sodium concentration in the cell is too high, the third gene will be turned off anyway, because the excess sodium prevents the change in conformation of the first protein. People have mapped out enourmous cascades of gene effects with many branches, feedback loops, multiple environmental and epigentic modifiers and so forth. Just about every gene is pleiotropic, meaning that is has more than one effect. Similarly, almost every gene has multiple things that determine when, where, and how strongly it is expressed. Genes can also have synergistic interactions, competitive interactions, and so on.
So the genetics allow for a large number of possibilities, meaning that even purely genetic traits can vary close to continuously. But very few traits are purely genetic. Human height certainly isn't. The nutritional state of your mother before and during her pregnancy has an effect on your height. So does your own nutrition during the time you are growing. My grandfathers, who were cold and hungry through much of their childhoods, were shorter than any of their male grandchildren. My grandmothers, similarly, were shorter than any of their granddaughters. We, and our parents, ate better, so we grew more. Most Americans are taller than their grandparents were, not because of any genetic change, but because our environment is different than theirs was.
Once again, there are non-linear interactions, both between environmental effects, and between environment and genes. In some cases organisms seem to be genetically programmed to let the environment have a very strong effect on their development. I won't go into detail because I think you get the picture. We are vastly complex systems, and their is ample opportunity for feedback, interference, competition and so forth. And given the number of inputs, and the complexity of the algorithm, continuous outputs are nearly inevitable. Even classical Mendelian traits are rarely all that discrete in their distribution if one allows environment to vary and does not have an inbred population.
As for growth thresholds, what tells a bone to stop getting longer now, and start growing internally instead, I know very little. The molecular basis of development is a very active field of research, but is far enough from my own that I haven't paid much attention to it.
Have I answered your question?
-Dan
There are several factors that can contribute to continuously varying traits, and we have to be careful not to conflate them. They are often divided into two broad categories, genetic factors and environmental factors, although there are often non-linear interactions between these.
On the genetic side, traits come in several flavors. The two state trait, where either you have it or you don't, is the classical Mendelian trait. Peas in a particualr population are white or green. If you have two alleles for green, or one for green and one for white, you make green peas. If you have no alleles that code for the green pigment, you make white peas. Next, as you described, are the three state genetic traits. Still all coded for at one locus, but dosage dependent, you end up with 0 or .5 or 1 full dose of the gene product. This is called incomplete dominance.
Then you get into additive multi-gene traits. Many different genetic loci have can affect human height, as an example. There was one gene, who's name I don't remember, that was recently shown to exhibit incomplete dominance in affecting human height. AA individuals are on average 5mm taller than the background population, Aa individuals are, on average, no different from the background population, and aa individuals are on average 5mm shorter than the mean of the population. But obviously height in humans varies by more than 1cm, so their must be other factors contributing. Some of these factors are genes affecting the length or shape of individual bones. Of those, some are classically dominant, some are incompletely dominant, and some may even be overdominant (where the Bb individual would have a longer bone than the BB or the bb). When you add together the variation in all these genes, you have a huge range of possible combinations, and end up with data that look pretty continuous. But then it gets even more complicated.
Genetic effects are not always additive. Imagine one gene codes for the presence a knob on a bone, and another gene causes that knob to be long or short. If an individual has the allele that causes that knob not to exist, it doesn't matter whether or not it has the allele that would make that knob long. If the knob isn't there, it can't be long. This is called epistasis. The sole effect of many genes, on a molecular level, is to regulate the activity of other genes. One gene makes a protein that carves up the protein product of a second gene, preventing that second protein from binding to a particular point on a chromosome where it would keep a third gene from being transcribed. Raise the temperature slightly, and the first protein changes conformation, and lets the second protein be, which cuts off production of the thrid gene. But if the Sodium concentration in the cell is too high, the third gene will be turned off anyway, because the excess sodium prevents the change in conformation of the first protein. People have mapped out enourmous cascades of gene effects with many branches, feedback loops, multiple environmental and epigentic modifiers and so forth. Just about every gene is pleiotropic, meaning that is has more than one effect. Similarly, almost every gene has multiple things that determine when, where, and how strongly it is expressed. Genes can also have synergistic interactions, competitive interactions, and so on.
So the genetics allow for a large number of possibilities, meaning that even purely genetic traits can vary close to continuously. But very few traits are purely genetic. Human height certainly isn't. The nutritional state of your mother before and during her pregnancy has an effect on your height. So does your own nutrition during the time you are growing. My grandfathers, who were cold and hungry through much of their childhoods, were shorter than any of their male grandchildren. My grandmothers, similarly, were shorter than any of their granddaughters. We, and our parents, ate better, so we grew more. Most Americans are taller than their grandparents were, not because of any genetic change, but because our environment is different than theirs was.
Once again, there are non-linear interactions, both between environmental effects, and between environment and genes. In some cases organisms seem to be genetically programmed to let the environment have a very strong effect on their development. I won't go into detail because I think you get the picture. We are vastly complex systems, and their is ample opportunity for feedback, interference, competition and so forth. And given the number of inputs, and the complexity of the algorithm, continuous outputs are nearly inevitable. Even classical Mendelian traits are rarely all that discrete in their distribution if one allows environment to vary and does not have an inbred population.
As for growth thresholds, what tells a bone to stop getting longer now, and start growing internally instead, I know very little. The molecular basis of development is a very active field of research, but is far enough from my own that I haven't paid much attention to it.
Have I answered your question?
-Dan
Sunday, January 13, 2008
Genetic Question for Dan
What is the genetic mechanism that controls continuously variable traits (height, bone thickness, pigmentation, etc.) ? I am aware the very simple case in flowers where the presence of normal petal color is determined by two copies of a gene, each of which produce a certain enzyme. A flower can have either zero, one or two copies of this gene, which results in a net production of the pigment enzyme in corresponding amounts of zero, about half-normal, or full-normal. The resulting flower color is then either pure white when there is no enzyme, whiteish-purple for medium enzyme levels, or deep purple when enzyme levels are fully normal. In principle, this is really a three-state set of trait values {0, 1/2, 1}. Although it is possible that environmental factors might cause the ½ level of enzyme to vary between individual flowers, resulting in a smearing out of the medium state in color space, such that the distribution of trait values appears to be a bit more continuous in the population
Is multi-gene encoding of enzyme/hormone levels the only way that continuously variable traits are controlled? What about genes being turned on and off? A single gene turns on and starts producing a certain growth hormone. The creature keeps growing until a certain condition is met, at which point the gene turns off, the hormone levels dwindle, and the creature’s shoe size has reached its maximum value. However, although only one gene encoded the recipe for the growth hormone, there must have been something else that prescribed the “turn off” condition, and that would be what is really responsible for the creature’s terminal value of shoe size. Different individuals with different shoe sizes would have identical growth hormone genes, but would have variation in the genes that encoded their shoe size via this “stop making hormone, my feet are big enough” mechanism. Unfortunately, we are right back to the fundamental question of how is a continuous numeric quantity is encoded by a set of genes. In this example, we would need to understand how the “hormone turn off” mechanism worked, and what knob in this mechanism could be continuously controlled via variation in some set of genes.
When you think about it, just about every little detail in an organism must have some sort of a control like this, since the length, curvature, and density of bones, muscles, organs, are all continuously variable during the growth of the organism. The final shape of each piece must be determined by possibly hundreds of specific dimensions and continuous quantities. How much is currently known about the mechanisms for encoding this information in our genome? If there are any serious flaws in my reasoning, or biological basics, please let me know, as I am very curious to understand this better.
Thanks
- Stephen
Is multi-gene encoding of enzyme/hormone levels the only way that continuously variable traits are controlled? What about genes being turned on and off? A single gene turns on and starts producing a certain growth hormone. The creature keeps growing until a certain condition is met, at which point the gene turns off, the hormone levels dwindle, and the creature’s shoe size has reached its maximum value. However, although only one gene encoded the recipe for the growth hormone, there must have been something else that prescribed the “turn off” condition, and that would be what is really responsible for the creature’s terminal value of shoe size. Different individuals with different shoe sizes would have identical growth hormone genes, but would have variation in the genes that encoded their shoe size via this “stop making hormone, my feet are big enough” mechanism. Unfortunately, we are right back to the fundamental question of how is a continuous numeric quantity is encoded by a set of genes. In this example, we would need to understand how the “hormone turn off” mechanism worked, and what knob in this mechanism could be continuously controlled via variation in some set of genes.
When you think about it, just about every little detail in an organism must have some sort of a control like this, since the length, curvature, and density of bones, muscles, organs, are all continuously variable during the growth of the organism. The final shape of each piece must be determined by possibly hundreds of specific dimensions and continuous quantities. How much is currently known about the mechanisms for encoding this information in our genome? If there are any serious flaws in my reasoning, or biological basics, please let me know, as I am very curious to understand this better.
Thanks
- Stephen
Key Words
genetics,
incomplete dominance,
quantitative genetics
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)